The Scholarly Paper
A few of my friends have returned to school and are pursuing degrees – or advanced degrees. I admire them greatly for it, but have never been particularly tempted to do so myself.
I have a basic bachelor’s degree, a BA in English – technical communications emphasis. I only worked in the field for a couple of years, but the skill has served me well throughout my career.
One friend has an executive MBA. A few have MBAs in telecommunications management. Another has her masters’ in project management. Others are working on resuming and finishing their bachelor’s degrees – general studies, information science, teaching, even math.
There’s nothing I am passionate enough about to spend 2-4 years on pursuing in graduate school. Sure, I like creative writing and fine arts – but not enough to pursue an academic degree in the subject matter, plus the return on investment isn’t really there.
In spite of my disregard for the whole going-back-to-school experience, I get to live it vicariously.
I’m the proud parent of a college sophomore. He’s pursing a degree in digital media engineering at the local community college, with a possible 4-year transfer. He typically sails through classes in his primary subject area, but some of the broader classes are a bit of a challenge.
His 8am class this fall is Effective Human Relations. (Are any positive human relations possible at 8am?) He’s writing the first of several analytical papers for the class, this week a critical analysis of a scholarly journal article on a management topic.
He chose “constructive criticism” as his topic and found an article on “Constructive Criticism and Social Lies: a Developmental Sequence for Understanding Honesty and Kindness in Social Interactions.” You’d think such an article would be pretty interesting; you’d be dead wrong. Academic writing can suck the life out of anything!
Tonight, my job begins with helping him understand the directions and ends with proofreading. No actual writing or – ugh – footnoting is required.
I sure don’t miss those days!












October 8th, 2009
Oh, c’mon. You know you want to join us…join us…join us…
October 8th, 2009
In my field, an advanced degree counts for very little in terms of, well, advancement. I know as many good tech leaders with just a basic B.S. in C.S. as I know people who have MBAs and what-have-you. I’ve been tempted to go for an MBA on occasion, but I always end up erring on the side of it being a waste of money.
My opinion of formal education in general is not very high (although I recognize that there are professional areas in which it is not only essential but even irreplaceable), so I’m not rushing back to school…
October 9th, 2009
Run from the advanced degree! Run!