My 18 year old elder son and I were talking, Sunday night, and he confessed to me that he had decided to call his birthday gift to his girlfriend a promise ring. He reads this blog from time to time – hi Ben! Please bear with me, I’m using your personal life to make a point here.
Ben was not even remotely straightforward with this information. The conversation started out with, “Hey mom, how much does it cost to get a ring resized?”, and went downhill from there. It was like prying nails to get each successive detail from him.
Nonetheless, she’s wearing a promise ring, at 17. And I’m not entirely sure it was Ben’s idea, but who knows?
Ben has always tended to have intense, monogamous, serious relationships. I was never that way in school, and my sister was always in a relationship. All teens are different.
I didn’t freak out at the news. It will either last, or it won’t, and any histrionics on my part will have not the slightest effect. What I did bring up was college. I also mentioned medical and auto insurance. We talked about this with both of our children.
We have some college savings, and intend to help our children through college – at minimum, 4 years of tuition, books & fees at a state college. Under some circumstances, we may help with living expenses if they live away from home for school, but they’ll need to get a job and help. The plan we’ve hit on is similar to an employer’s tuition reimbursement plan – the kids have to come up with their first semester’s tuition, and front that money – and upon successful completion, we’ll reimburse it and they can then use it to enroll in the second semester. We feel this will help give them a personal stake in their progress.
BUT… if they get married during college, that’s it. Nada, nothing, the money well dries up. College is for learning. Marriage should wait until after they finish college, and establish an adult life that starts with being self supporting. In addition, should either boy choose to get married during college, he will no longer be eligible for medical or auto insurance on our plans.
The boys were surprised by this. They didn’t quite get it. They felt that a personal choice on their part to alter their marital status should in no way impact the parental subsidy. We explained that as long as a parental subsidy exists, they have no business getting married and committing to financially partner with another person.
They still didn’t like it, but the line has been drawn.
The other aspect of this that makes me sad is that Ben, Mr. Monogamy that he is, has swallowed the myth of the traditional romance, hook, line and sinker. It goes something like this:
- I like this person, therefore I should ask him/her out
- I really like this person, therefore I should see him/her exclusively
- I really like this person, therefore I should fall in love with this person
- I love this person, therefore I should marry him/her
WHY???? Why is it an automatic escalation model? It’s a lie, young girls are programmed with it, and boys often buy into it too. Why can’t we:
- Become great friends with people of the opposite sex without needing to date?
- Date and have a great time without needing to be exclusive?
- Date for enjoyment and personal growth without it having to lead to something serious?
- Date someone you really care about without having to be “in love”?
- Love someone and experience an independent relationship without having to get married?
There are plenty of times that the next step is not at all appropriate. How many of us have talked yourselves into being in love? How many of us have loved someone entirely inappropriate, and got married because, well, marriage was what came next after love?
I’m sad that Ben is going through the rote motions of the traditional romance so early and so earnestly. I’m sad that either he or his girlfriend are pretty likely to be hurt by it. I wish that they could just date, have fun and grow together. I wish they had a relationship that would allow the independence they both need at this stage of their lives – to go to college, to have independent friends, their own lives, and the faith and dreams that will shape them into the adult they need to be.
Ben isn’t thinking about this from an idealistic or long-term perspective, he’s young and impulsive. Nonetheless, if he gets married while he’s in college, it’s going to be a painful lesson for us all.